Car Insurance Rates After Accident (Oops, It Wasn’t My fault)

So, you just got in a car accident and want to know what will happen with your insurance rates. Well first off, if the fault wasn’t yours then there shouldn’t be any change at all. Many states have laws against raising someone else’s premiums due to their own negligence so make sure your state has this law on the books before jumping into conclusions about how much extra money you’ll need each month.

Driver With No Insurance

If the driver who doesn’t have car insurance caused the accident, there would be no change to your rate either way because you’re not at fault, and this is an uninsured case.

 If it’s the other person’s fault, but they do have insurance, you will want to determine if that insurance pays for your medical bills. If it does, you will not have to pay for any part of the accident, and there is no way your rates change. 

Suppose they don’t cover your medical expenses. In that case, you want to ask if that person has enough liability coverage on their policy because then this would be considered a requirement by law.

Suppose you don’t have enough liability coverage and the other person’s insurance does cover your medical bills. In that case, they can choose to sue that driver for damages. If they do this successfully, it will reduce their car insurance rates significantly because they’ve helped lower your costs as well.

The costs for your auto insurance will likely increase by 20% to 30%. This is because the cost of repairs or replacement can vary greatly depending on who’s at fault and what coverage was in place before the accident. 

For example, suppose your car was totaled in an accident, and you have collision coverage. In that case, your insurer will pay for the damages. If they don’t have that type of coverage, then it’s up to you or whoever is at fault to cover those costs as well.

When does car insurance go down after accident

It is all based on the type of coverage in place before the accident. If you have collision insurance, your rates will go down after an accident because they’ll cover any damages caused by somebody else and pay for repairs or replacement. If you don’t have that kind of coverage, your rates may go up.

This type of coverage before the accident determines how much risk there was for that driver and their rates. If they don’t have collision insurance, their premiums are a lot higher to cover potential damages from an incident like this.

How high insurance rates are after an accident can vary depending on the course of the trip and the accident’s severity. Your insurer can adjust your rate after an accident to consider new information about your driving history. Your insurer may not increase your rate in certain states if the accident damage is less than a certain dollar amount.   

Getting involved in a car accident where you are at fault can significantly increase your car insurance rates. If it turns out that you are to blame for the accident, you are likely to see an increase in your auto insurance at the time of renewal.    

 Car insurance premiums average rise three years after a guilty accident, while insurance premiums average drop after three years—the average annual cost of comprehensive insurance increases by 4.6% for each driver after an accident. The driver has been proven to have caused the injury.    

Many motorists worry that an accident will increase their insurance rates. Depending on the type of accident or the damage to the car, you may see an increase in your insurance rate.   

An accident while driving or a driving violation can be a red flag for insurers and cause car rates to rise.    

How much your car rate rises or falls depends on a number of factors, including your insurer, the state in which you live, a previous accident or an Accident Control violation, and your age. 

If the car accident is your fault and leads to an injury, you can expect an average increase of $1,157 a year or a 46 percent increase in the rate. The specific increase in rates depends on the details of the car accident and your driving behavior.    

Many people are afraid to report car accidents to their insurance company after an accident because car insurance rates increase with each claim over time. An accident stays in your account for up to five years, during which time you pay a higher rate for car insurance. 

Even a blameless accident can affect your car insurance, depending on the insurance company and state, but usually for three or five years.  

If the car insurance company increases your rate after an accident, it’s hard to know how much right away. Suppose an accident premium is added to a new car insurance policy. 

If you experienced this, you might be able to exceed your old rate. While car insurance looks like a bargain at first glance, a big premium can send your tariff through the roof even without an accident.

For instance, the minimum liability requirement by Georgia state law will be $25,000 per person for personal injury liability, $50,000 if no personal injury or liability has occurred in the accident and $25,000 for property liability insurance. Indebted drivers without insurance must pay for damages, regardless of whether the driver is insured or not. 

If your insurance does not provide accident insurance, not only will your rate rise after an accident, but even if you are not at fault, the insurance provider must be more specific.    

If your insurer raises rates after an accident you were not at fault for, you should consider switching insurers. Look around and go to a higher-risk insurer that will offer you a lower rate. The after-effect of a car accident can be an excellent time to search for cheaper car insurance, but if your current policy is not the best option for you, the price can go up.

 The biggest question, aside from how much your auto insurance will rise after an accident, is whether you should get the lowest possible premium for your accident if possible.    

The more accident cards you have on your logbook, the higher your car insurance premium will be. If an accident follows you for three to five years, no car insurer can exceed your current rate.    

Many people will not increase rates after the first accident. Still, if you have a pattern of accidents that are not your fault, you may see your premiums rise because the company puts you in a higher risk pool. 

The type of accident or claim that increases your rate is an accident through no fault of your own, an accident that you have caused and that increases your insurance prices.    

If the car accident is your fault, does it affect your credit?

Being in a vehicle accident has no impact on your credit score. Still, a lower credit rating can lead to higher premiums. An accident you are responsible for can make more expensive premiums. Though that’s not always the case for every company, so it’s wise to look for the best rates before comparing car insurance. 

Even if you have multiple accidents by no fault of your own that increase your perceived risk to the insurance provider, you can still drive into a higher risk accident situation regardless of whether you are liable or not.    

Many automobile insurance companies offer “accident forgiveness” or “safe driving” programs that waive interest rates and reward you for being accident-free. These programs can prevent car insurance rates from rising or at least keep prices down. 

Cheap car insurance after accident

The first answer is not to settle for the first policy that seems decent because the price isn’t everything. It would help if you had protection and coverage, so be sure to compare quotes from different providers before deciding.

List Cheap Car Insurance Companies

*Company names are listed in alphabetical order*


An AARP car insurance company has an insurance plan to meet the needs of drivers who have had a prior accident.

It’s called “Cheap Car Insurance After Accident,” and it is specifically designed for people who have been involved in accidents and need affordable, high-quality coverage that won’t break their budget.

To get this coverage, the driver has to be a member of AARP. There is no minimum age policy for membership. This insurance company was designed specifically with people over 50 in mind, but it’s open to anyone who meets those requirements. 

Membership can cost as little as $16 per year and includes benefits like discounts on car repair and maintenance, discounts on prescription drugs, identity theft protection services for only $16 per year.

The insurance company is available nationwide through a variety of agents. It provides the driver with an affordable way to get cheap car insurance after an accident without having to worry about being unfairly penalized because they’ve had an accident in the past.

Website –


Allstate plan allows drivers who have been in any collision or accident to get affordable rates on their auto insurance with as little as $100 deductible per incident.

In the last few years, car accidents and collisions have increased significantly due to more cars on the road and drivers who are very distracted or drunk. That’s why Allstate, one of the largest auto insurance providers in North America, is making this offer to protect families from high car insurance rates after an accident.



Esurance has two car insurance types: Comprehensive and Collision.

The best option for you is Comprehensive, but Collision will get you the same basic coverage if you don’t qualify for that. And since your car is already damaged, Esurance pays to repair it. The only thing unpaid is the medical bills and a fine from the state of California.

This means you get the same level of coverage but for less money. If you’re still not convinced about switching to Esurance, read on below.

If you are at fault, With Esurance insurance company, for cheap car insurance after an accident you get:

Collision: This is the most comprehensive car insurance that you can get. It covers repair costs, damages to the other car, medical bills, and fines. Esurance Collision provides the same coverage as Comprehensive but for a lower premium. “Backing up” will also save you money. It’s not necessary to purchase a specific type of auto insurance.

Comprehensive: If you did not hit another car, Esurance provides you with a cheaper premium than Comprehensive. 

Even if you at fault in the accident and your car was damaged, it’s still a good option. The downside is that it only covers up to $25,000 worth of damages in six months. And there’s also no medical coverage or state fine – and you pay for both.

Medical Payments:

 If you need to get medical attention, Esurance will help pay the bills. You can get up to $1,000 of medical coverage per person, but only $3,000 for family.

Uninsured Motorist: 

It is a good option if an uninsured driver has hit you. It covers the same damages as Collision and Comprehensive above, but for less money.

Underinsured Motorist: This is also a good option after getting hit by an uninsured driver – and it’s cheaper than Medical Payments. 

If the driver who caused the accident and has insurance, then you can get your damages covered. If they don’t, then they will have to pay for some of the damage.

Other Options Besides Esurance

It is worth noting that you also have a few other options if you are at fault in an accident. Your state may have a no-fault auto insurance program, and each state will have its fee structure.


USAA offers cheap car insurance after accident program. However, it isn’t available to everyone. If you were involved in an accident that wasn’t your fault and insured through USAA, you are eligible for this program.

The program applies to all kinds of automobile accidents: various types of collisions except head-on or those involving pedestrians or bicyclists, and rollovers are all covered. In addition, if your car is damaged by an uninsured driver or from hitting a deer or other object, this program will cover you.

 If you get into a multi-vehicle accident and your injuries are not too serious, this low-cost auto insurance may be for you as well.

This type of insurance is available to all USAA members who are at or below the poverty level and are not eligible for any type of federal, state or other organization’s low-cost auto insurance program. 

In other words, it is offered for people who otherwise would have to pay more than $6,000 a year in auto insurance. If you qualify, you maybe eligible to receive a discount.

Plus, this cheap car insurance after accident program can help if you are filing a claim. For instance, in a car accident you are at fault, your deductible will be lowered to $250.

In addition, if you are covered by USAA and your vehicle is damaged by an uninsured driver or hit by a deer or other object, you can file an insurance claim for up to $500 (or the full value of the car with some limitations).

You need to meet a few other conditions to get this cheap auto insurance after accident program. You need to be a member of USAA, and you must retain the use of your vehicle. In addition, you must be able to pay your portion of the deductible out-of-pocket.

Be sure to check with USAA about the specifics of this program because it may have changed since the publication of this article. If you’re not a member of USAA, this doesn’t mean that you can’t get cheap car insurance after an accident.

Website –

In conclusion

Use accident prevention programs when looking for the best insurance rates to help you find the cheapest policy, regardless of whether there is an accident or not.